Dichotomous Key by Kasey Petrochko

2 Comments

  1. Steph the TA

    Hi Kasey –

    Great indenting – thank you for that! It makes reading a key much easier.

    Each couplet will belong to the same letter – one is plain (A), the other designated by the prime (A’). This is because it’s describing a single feature (vegetative part, reproductive part, etc.). Also, if a descriptor of a couplet is not resolving to a plant, it needs to point to an appropriate later couplet (A’ Plant has glitter -> B).

    Also, couplets usually describe opposites – they describe a condition and the lack of that condition. So… “Has glitter” vs. “Lacks glitter”. Then proceed as appropriate.

    In your first couplet (A, A’): that’s not a pine cone. I.e., it’s not from a tree belonging to Genus Pinus. It IS a cone – and a true, woody cone at that. It’s okay to keep it simple.

    Your second couplet is not as helpful or descriptive as it might seem. Does “thick” mean the leaf is broad/wide (like a lily pad, for instance), or does it mean it’s tough (like Labrador tea)? Or does it mean something else? You see, I would have said Plant 2 had thin leaves – it might be hard to see in the photo, but they’re tiny and hugging the stem. Is there something more obvious to differentiate Plants 2, 3 and 4 – especially since Plant 4 doesn’t actually have petals? (It IS a flower, yes… but no petals. That’s the third thing.)

    Go ahead and give it another shot.
    Steph

  2. Shooka Dalilak

    Hey Kasey, I think you could be a little more specific on what thick versus thin leaves means in your post. I do think you could also leave it at “has cones” as they are not pine cones in the picture, although they do like pinecones. Otherwise, I like your formatting and I think you did good besides those few changes!

Comments are closed.